Koinly vs Other Crypto Tax Software: Which One Fits Your Portfolio?

Ameli

— 3 min read

Cryptocurrency investing and trading have grown rapidly — and so has the complexity of reporting taxes correctly. With a plethora of crypto tax tools available, choosing the right one for your portfolio can save you time, stress, and even money. In this article, we’ll compare Koinly with other leading crypto tax platforms, highlight strengths and weaknesses, and help you decide which software best fits your needs in 2026.

Why Crypto Tax Software Matters in 2026

As crypto regulations tighten globally, exchanges increasingly report transaction details directly to tax authorities, making accurate reporting essential. Whether you’re an active DeFi user, NFT trader, or long‑term HODLer, having reliable crypto tax software helps you:

  • Track and organize transactions across wallets and exchanges
  • Calculate gains, losses, and income correctly
  • Generate tax‑compliant reports and forms
  • Avoid underpayment penalties or audits

Choosing a tool that matches the complexity of your portfolio is key.

Koinly: A Quick Overview

Koinly is one of the most popular crypto tax tools, known for strong blockchain and wallet support, international tax reporting, and a user‑friendly interface. It supports hundreds of exchanges, thousands of tokens, and integrates with major tax reporting formats.

Pros

  • Extensive integrations: Over 1,000 supported exchanges, wallets, and blockchains with many automatic API connections.
  • International coverage: Supports tax reports for 100+ countries.
  • Feature‑rich free plan: Allows full portfolio tracking, tax preview, and even a tax loss harvesting simulation.
  • Flexible accounting methods: FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, and customizable settings.

Cons

  • Transaction limits on paid plans are per tax year rather than lifetime, which may matter for high‑volume traders.

Comparing Top Crypto Tax Tools

1. Koinly vs CoinTracker

CoinTracker is another well‑known crypto tax platform, with some similarities to Koinly, but also key differences:

  • Pricing: CoinTracker’s plans start slightly higher (~$59/year) compared to Koinly’s ~ $49/year option.
  • Integrations: Koinly generally has broader wallet and blockchain support, including more automatic API integrations, reducing manual CSV uploads. CoinTracker relies more on CSVs.
  • Free features: Koinly gives richer free access — including portfolio tracking and tax summary previews — whereas CoinTracker limits these behind paid plans.
  • User experience: Both are user‑friendly, but Koinly’s error‑flagging and guidance tools make reconciling historical transactions easier before paying.

👉 Best for: Users with multiple wallets/DeFi activity who want extensive integration and preview features before upgrading.

2. Koinly vs CoinLedger

CoinLedger (formerly CryptoTrader.Tax) is often compared with Koinly because both support DeFi and NFT reporting:

  • Integrations: Koinly generally supports more exchanges, wallets, and blockchains, which matters if you trade across many platforms.
  • International tax reporting: Koinly supports more countries than CoinLedger, which focuses on a smaller list.
  • Ease of use: Some users find CoinLedger slightly more intuitive out of the box, especially for first‑time users, but Koinly’s powerful tracking tools and detailed documentation balance that out.
  • Free features: Koinly includes almost all features in its free tier (except downloading reports).

👉 Best for: Traders who need broad global tax support and large‑scale wallet integrations.

3. Other Tools to Consider

Aside from Koinly, CoinTracker, and CoinLedger, there are other competent platforms worth mentioning:

  • CoinTracking: Very feature‑rich with customizable imports and analysis — but can require more manual cleanup.
  • ZenLedger: Known for strong customer support and wide exchange coverage but tends to be pricier.
  • Accointing / Coinpanda: Good for smaller portfolios or basic DeFi/NFT needs but may lack advanced global tax reporting features compared to Koinly.

Each has its strengths, so consider your unique needs — such as number of transactions, blockchain activity, and country of residence — before deciding.

Which One Fits Your Portfolio?

Here’s a quick guide to help you decide:

✔️ You trade across many wallets, blockchains, DeFi protocols, or NFTs? → Koinly
✔️ You want a simpler, user‑friendly interface with strong cost reporting? → CoinLedger
✔️ You want advanced tax optimization features and enterprise‑level management? → CoinTracker or ZenLedger
✔️ You need deep analytical exports with customizable reports? → CoinTracking

Tips for Choosing Crypto Tax Software

  1. Check integrations first. The fewer manual CSV uploads, the less room for errors.
  2. Estimate your yearly transactions before picking a plan. High volumes may warrant a higher tier.
  3. Verify tax form support for your jurisdiction (e.g., IRS Form 8949 in the US or ATO in Australia).
  4. Try free tiers first to see which interface you prefer.

Conclusion

In 2026, crypto tax software is more essential than ever. Koinly stands out for its integration breadth, global tax support, and feature‑rich free tier, making it appealing for a wide range of users. But other tools like CoinTracker and CoinLedger may fit different portfolios depending on your priorities — ease of use, advanced reporting, or specific tax optimization features.

The best fit depends on how you trade, where you live, and how complex your activity is — so take advantage of free trials and explore each platform before committing.

Read more